On 3 June 2026 the EU General Court declared invalid Tetra Laval’s three-dimensional EU trade mark for its octagonal drinks carton, because the shape’s essential characteristics are necessary to obtain a technical result (case T-104/25, ECLI:EU:T:2026:365). The ruling shows the limits of a shape trade mark in the EU: if packaging works better because of its form, trade mark law will not protect that form. It matters most to food and beverage exporters, including Latin American brands, that rely on a distinctive container.
Key takeaways
- A shape whose essential characteristics all perform a technical function cannot be an EU trade mark, however well known it is.
- Saving material, reducing weight, easing storage and transport, and a better grip all counted as technical results linked to use.
- It did not matter that other shapes could achieve the same result, or that one feature also looked distinctive.
- The owner’s own patent application and marketing claims were used as evidence against it.
- Packaging needs a layered strategy: design, patent and trade marks on the non-functional elements.
What did the General Court decide in Tetra Laval (T-104/25)?
Tetra Laval Holdings & Finance applied on 19 April 2000 to register its octagonal carton shape for packaging in class 16. On 3 January 2022, Lami Packaging (Kunshan) Co. Ltd, a company based in China, applied to the EUIPO to have it declared invalid.
| Date | Body | Outcome |
|---|---|---|
| 6 November 2023 | EUIPO Cancellation Division | Mark declared invalid: shape necessary to obtain a technical result |
| 6 December 2024 | EUIPO Fourth Board of Appeal (R 12/2024-4) | Decision reversed: the technical benefits concerned manufacturing, not use |
| 3 June 2026 | General Court, extended chamber of five judges (T-104/25) | Board’s decision annulled and altered: the mark is invalid; EUIPO pays Lami’s costs |
Because the application dates from 2000, the Court applied the old Regulation 40/94, whose Article 7(1)(e)(ii) is in substance identical to the current Article 7(1)(e)(ii) of Regulation (EU) 2017/1001. The EU IP Helpdesk summarised the ruling on 19 June 2026.
Why was the octagonal carton excluded?
The Court followed the two-step test from the Lego case. First, it identified four essential characteristics: an octagonal brick with truncated corners, concave corner surfaces, wall panels that narrow in the middle, and a top sealing fin with folded flaps. Second, it asked whether all of them perform a technical function.
The Court accepted the Board’s starting point, taken from the Court of Justice’s Nestlé judgment (C-215/14): only technical results that show up when the product is used count, not savings in how it is made. But it found the Board had applied that rule wrongly. On the evidence, especially Tetra Laval’s 1996 PCT patent application and its own website, the shape:
- lets the carton do its basic job of holding liquids while staying stable and easy to handle;
- holds more product for the same amount of packaging material;
- makes the carton lighter and less bulky, which helps the food companies that fill, store and ship it;
- gives consumers a more comfortable grip.
Three further points close the usual escape routes. The result does not need to be an improvement or patentable. The existence of alternative shapes is irrelevant. And a feature that is necessary for a technical result stays excluded even if it also has aesthetic value.
What does this mean for a shape trade mark in the EU?
The technical-function ground is absolute and cannot be cured by use. Under Article 7(3) of the EU Trade Mark Regulation, acquired distinctiveness overcomes only the grounds in Article 7(1)(b), (c) and (d), not the shape exclusions in 7(1)(e). A famous carton can still be invalidated, decades after filing.
The same logic exists in the Andean Community: Decision 486 accepts product and packaging shapes as marks (Article 134) but excludes shapes that give a functional or technical advantage (Article 135(d)), again without the acquired-distinctiveness exception.
What this means for your business
- Audit your packaging marks: list which features are technical (capacity, stacking, sealing, grip) and which are purely ornamental.
- Protect the look with a design. A registered EU design lasts five years, renewable up to 25, and the EUIPO fee is EUR 350 for the first design. File early, ideally before the packaging reaches the market, because a design must be new when it is filed.
- Protect the engineering with a patent, accepting that it expires.
- Build trade marks on what is not functional: word marks, labels, colour combinations and decorative elements.
- Align marketing with your IP strategy. Claims such as “uses less material” or “easier to grip” can later be used to prove functionality.
For exporters planning packaging protection in Europe and Latin America together, our trademark and shape mark team works alongside our industrial design registration service so that each feature gets the right right.
Where companies get this wrong
- Treating a 3D mark as a perpetual patent. That is exactly what Article 7(1)(e)(ii) prevents.
- Filing patents that describe the shape’s advantages, then claiming the same shape as a trade mark.
- Relying on fame. Recognition does not cure functionality.
- Launching first and thinking about a design later, when the packaging may no longer count as new.
Frequently asked questions
Can a packaging shape be registered as an EU trade mark?
Yes, if it is distinctive and its essential characteristics are not all dictated by the nature of the goods, by a technical result or by substantial value. If every essential feature serves a technical function, as the General Court found for Tetra Laval’s octagonal carton in T-104/25, the shape is excluded, even if the public recognises it.
Does it help that competitors could use a different shape?
No. The General Court confirmed that, under Article 7(1)(e)(ii), the analysis looks at whether the shape is necessary to obtain a technical result, without comparing it with other shapes on the market. The availability of alternatives does not save a functional shape from exclusion.
Did the Court rule on bad faith in the Tetra Laval case?
No. Lami had also argued bad faith, but the Board of Appeal rejected that ground and Lami did not challenge that part before the General Court. The Court noted that the grounds of invalidity are independent, so the technical-function ground alone was enough to declare the mark invalid.
Can IP Global Guard review the protection of our packaging?
Yes. We map which features of your packaging can be protected as trade marks, designs or patents, and coordinate filings before the EUIPO, directly where our professionals are entitled and through qualified representatives otherwise, and before national offices in Latin America and Africa through local correspondents.
How IP Global Guard protects packaging that sells
Tetra Laval shows that one right is rarely enough to protect a distinctive container. IP Global Guard, the IP services line of META Channel Corporation Limited, combines trade mark, design and patent strategy across more than 25 jurisdictions in Europe, Latin America and Africa, with one point of contact.
Send us images of your packaging, the markets where you sell and any patents or designs you already hold. We will tell you which features are at risk and how to cover them. Ask for a packaging protection review.
This article is general information, not legal advice, and reflects the position on its publication date.
Sources
- General Court, judgment of 3 June 2026, Lami Packaging v EUIPO – Tetra Laval, T-104/25, ECLI:EU:T:2026:365
- European IP Helpdesk, news on the Tetra Laval octagonal carton judgment (19 June 2026)
- WIPO Lex, Regulation (EU) 2017/1001 on the European Union trade mark (14 June 2017)
- Andean Community, Decision 486, Common Industrial Property Regime (2000)
- EUIPO, Benefits of registering an EU design
- EUIPO, Design fees and payments








